Wheel of Fortune contestant goes viral over cheesy blunder as fans all say same thing
A Wheel of Fortune contestant went viral after guessing the wrong cheese dish. Viewers at home quickly caught the moment and agreed it was one of the ‘worst’ answers

Wheel of Fortune contestant goes viral (Image: Wheel of Fortune)
A Wheel of Fortune contestant has gone viral over a blunder.
On the Monday, Dec. 30 episode of the game show, Gaelyn Nease from Tallahassee, Florida, Carmetta Wells from Los Angeles, California, and Mike Tomani from Rochester, New York, tried to figure out the letters in the word puzzle to try to win big at the end.
There was a moment when the three had to guess the letters to the ‘Food and Drink category. Gaelyn was on a roll, guessing multiple letters correctly, leaving the board with “NE _ / _ OR _ / _ HEESE _ A _ E.” When it was time to solve it, she thought of a different kind of cheese dish than the correct one.
Gaelyn guessed: “New York Cheesesteak.”

The contestant guessed the wrong answer
Carmetta quickly swooped in with the correct answer – “Cheesecake” – which helped her to win a trip to New York City, including a VIP ticket to Dick Clark’s New Year’s Rockin’ Eve hosted by Ryan Seacrest. She also walked away from Wheel of Fortune with $68,250, while Mike won $17,700 and Gaelyn ended up with $2,000.
The moment went viral with viewers at home calling Gaelyn’s answer one of the worst in Wheel of Fortune history. One person on X, formerly known as Twitter wrote: “I was watching. Worst I’ve ever seen ‘live’ on tv. What a nerd.” Another posted: “I’ve never heard of a New York Cheesecake in my life.” A third user wrote: “I’ve heard of cheesecake, and I’ve heard of New York, but I’ve never heard of ‘New York Cheesecake.'” A fourth wrote: “A new all-time horrible answer.”
This is not the first time a contest has gone viral on the show. During the Thursday, May 23 episode, Tavaris, a contestant, had the audience laughing and shocked when he answered the “Phrase” category. The contestants were left to solve the puzzle and fill in the following missing letters, “_ _ _ _ I_ T_E B_ _T!”
Tavaris guessed and said: “Right in the butt?”
Not only was the audience laughing but people at home. Pat Sajak, former host of the show, was not amused and responded, “No.”
News
Kelly Clarkson Reveals She Never Got the $1 Million She Thought She Won on American Idol
A recent comment from American Idol’s first-ever winner has unexpectedly reignited discussion about the show’s early prize promises. Kelly Clarkson, who won the inaugural season of the competition, recently joked during a broadcast that she never actually received the $1…
Hannah Harper’s Heavy Spotlight Sparks Claims American Idol Already Picked Its Winner
Although American Idol Season 26 is still in its early elimination stages, some viewers are already convinced the competition has a frontrunner – and possibly a pre-planned narrative. That contestant, according to growing online discussions, is Hannah Harper. Fans have…
American Idol Fans Furious as Emotional Bryant Thomas Exit Sparks Favoritism Claims
The latest elimination on American Idol has sparked a wave of debate among viewers after contestant Bryant Thomas was sent home following what many considered a heartfelt but flawed performance. Bryant chose a powerful song for the round – Landslide…
American Idol Accused of Hiding Performances Online, Fans Say It’s Unfair to Contestants
A growing number of American Idol viewers are voicing frustration after realizing that the show’s official YouTube channel does not upload every performance from its episodes. What began as a simple attempt to catch up on missed broadcasts has quickly…
Arrest of American Idol’s Dimitrius Graham Sparks Backlash Over the Show American Idol
American Idol is once again facing scrutiny after former contestant Dimitrius Graham was reportedly arrested by Los Angeles police earlier this week. The news has quickly spread online, reigniting debate about the show’s vetting process and long-term responsibility toward its…
American Idol Season 24 Backlash: The Show Feels “Curated,” Over-Produced and Harder to Connect With
For some longtime viewers, American Idol Season 24 doesn’t feel like the show they once rushed home to watch. A growing conversation online suggests that something about this year’s format feels different and not everyone is thrilled about it. One…
End of content
No more pages to load