Carrie Underwood Is Not Okay in Tear-Filled American Idol First Look
One American Idol season 23 contestant makes new judge Carrie Underwood cry pretty in emotional new promo for the ABC singing competition series, which premieres March 9.
Get ready to cry pretty with Carrie Underwood.
The American Idol season four winner finally takes her seat at the judges’ table in E! News’ exclusive sneak peek at season 23 of the ABC reality singing competition series.
“This show is for people that have the talent, have a dream,” the “Cry Pretty” singer says in the new promo, “and they just need a chance.”

It isn’t long before Underwood is brought to tears by one contestant’s emotional life story during the auditions.
“My grandparents raised me from the moment I turned 2,” the hopeful tells the country star and fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan before being joined by his family. “She put everything she had in me all these years.”
Cut to Underwood ugly crying and blowing her nose.
And when Bryan jokingly asks, “You okay over there?” the emotional Underwood says through tears, “I’m not,” before Bryan comforts her with a giant hug.
Feelings aside, it’s safe to say the male singer’s vocal chops impressed the trio.
As Richie tells the contestant, “You need to be heard,” before he, Underwood and Bryan yell in unison, “You’re going to Hollywood!”
Of course, many other unknown talents are also hoping to earn a golden ticket with their auditions.
“I’ve wanted this since I was a little kid,” one admits in the teaser while another shares, “I’m ready for my life to change.”
And, yes, the first look promises many more tears of joy to come, both from the judges and the competitors. As Richie notes, “There are surprises in every person.”
See the emotional sneak peek at Underwood’s judging debut in the preview above.
As for how Underwood really feels about returning to Idol as a mentor 20 years after winning the show?
“I think I can be honest and constructive, but still kind,” the 41-year-old teased last August after it was announced she was replacing longtime judge Katy Perry. “And I think that’s the whole point, because people are coming in and it’s dreams. You’re part of somebody’s story from that moment on.”
ABC/Disney
Plus, Underwood already has her predecessor’s stamp of approval.
“She was born on that show,” Perry told People in January. “She actually truly knows. As artists, we’ve been in some sort of their shoes, but she has lived every single day. So I think she’s going to have a lot to offer anyone that’s willing to listen.”
American Idol premieres Sunday, March 9, at 8 p.m. on ABC.
News
Kelly Clarkson Reveals She Never Got the $1 Million She Thought She Won on American Idol
A recent comment from American Idol’s first-ever winner has unexpectedly reignited discussion about the show’s early prize promises. Kelly Clarkson, who won the inaugural season of the competition, recently joked during a broadcast that she never actually received the $1…
Hannah Harper’s Heavy Spotlight Sparks Claims American Idol Already Picked Its Winner
Although American Idol Season 26 is still in its early elimination stages, some viewers are already convinced the competition has a frontrunner – and possibly a pre-planned narrative. That contestant, according to growing online discussions, is Hannah Harper. Fans have…
American Idol Fans Furious as Emotional Bryant Thomas Exit Sparks Favoritism Claims
The latest elimination on American Idol has sparked a wave of debate among viewers after contestant Bryant Thomas was sent home following what many considered a heartfelt but flawed performance. Bryant chose a powerful song for the round – Landslide…
American Idol Accused of Hiding Performances Online, Fans Say It’s Unfair to Contestants
A growing number of American Idol viewers are voicing frustration after realizing that the show’s official YouTube channel does not upload every performance from its episodes. What began as a simple attempt to catch up on missed broadcasts has quickly…
Arrest of American Idol’s Dimitrius Graham Sparks Backlash Over the Show American Idol
American Idol is once again facing scrutiny after former contestant Dimitrius Graham was reportedly arrested by Los Angeles police earlier this week. The news has quickly spread online, reigniting debate about the show’s vetting process and long-term responsibility toward its…
American Idol Season 24 Backlash: The Show Feels “Curated,” Over-Produced and Harder to Connect With
For some longtime viewers, American Idol Season 24 doesn’t feel like the show they once rushed home to watch. A growing conversation online suggests that something about this year’s format feels different and not everyone is thrilled about it. One…
End of content
No more pages to load