[OFFICIAL] Carrie Underwood Breaks Her Silence About Returning to ‘American Idol’: Report

Carrie Underwood “On the Fence” About Returning to ‘American Idol’: Report

Although fans rejoiced over Jamal Roberts winning season 23 of American Idol, many wondered about Carrie Underwood and if she would return for another season. After replacing Katy Perry on the show, the country star sat between Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan as they searched for the next American Idol.

Will Carrie Underwood Return to 'American Idol'?

Bring not only years’ worth of experience, but Underwood knew the pressure of standing on the American Idol stage. Able to use her past to help navigate the contestants throughout season 23, the question now is – will Underwood return next year for season 24?

While Perry stayed with American Idol for several years, Underwood’s future with the show remained a topic of discussion throughout the season. And with the show returning for another season in 2026, an insider discussed Underwood’s future, telling The Sun, “After all the bumps this season, and the beginning was bumpy, the people that matter in the decision making, the powers that be, really love Carrie.” They added, “They feel a certain protectiveness toward her. They’ve defended any setbacks and criticism she’s endured this season and would gladly have her back.”

Carrie Underwood is returning to 'American Idol' as judge, replacing Katy Perry

With Underwood gaining support from the producers, it was now up to the singer to decided what she wanted to do. “The ball is more in Carrie’s court. She’s on the fence about coming back, there were times this season I think she would’ve absolutely said ‘no’ to returning. But as she’s found her place within the role it’s grown on her more but it wouldn’t surprise anyone on set if she doesn’t return.”

Carrie Underwood A Good Deal For ‘American Idol’

Even when Underwood praised Roberts on his victory, she stumbled when it came to revealing her plans for season 24. Not giving a definite answer, the insider noted, “This show was out of her comfort zone in many ways and was a far different experience than she was expecting.”

Looking at the reception Underwood received during the season, many fans loved the idea of bringing the former winner back. At the same time, the producers apparently enjoyed the money they saved. “She’s relatively cheap when comparing her salary to Katy or other big names who were approached to doing the show which is another big reason the show wants her.”

While Underwood’s future sat in limbo for now, only time will tell if the singer will expand her legacy on American Idol.

(Photo by Christopher Willard/Disney via Getty Images)